As families turn to homeschooling due to lack of information (or what they see as unacceptable or impractical policies) from public school systems about what fall may bring, they have questions. One of the most common questions we are seeing is whether curricula they are interested in is accredited.
|
Why accredited curriculum is in demand
Many families intend to return to public schools when things return to normal (or a more acceptable new normal), so “accreditation” seems like a good way to smooth re-entrance into public school. This is a perfectly rational thought process.
So to the question...
Is <fill-in-the-blank> curriculum accredited?
Nope, nope, nope!
You don’t need accredited curriculum for homeschooling.
And it’s a good thing, since curriculum cannot be accredited!
And guess what? Veteran homeschoolers—you know, the ones who have been at it years before the current situation (including the ones you hear about getting into great colleges)—don’t use accredited curriculum either!
Because there is No. Such. Thing. As. Accredited. Curriculum.
How accreditation works
Accreditation is offered to institutions by accrediting agencies (different agencies accredit public schools, private schools, and university model schools at the primary/secondary level, and a whole different set accredits institutions of higher education). These schools and universities can be accredited because they are institutions.
Curricula aren’t accredited (not ever!) because they aren’t schools or colleges. Curricula are learning resources or lesson plans; curricula are not institutions—so, they can’t be accredited!
Some people who opt their kids out of public school do enroll their kids in accredited private schools or accredited online schools, and the child might be “at home” while they are taking part in the accredited private or online school.
Is an accredited school a guarantee of credit transfer?
Transferring back to public school from an accredited private school or accredited online school is still no guarantee of grade placement or credits toward a public school diploma/graduation. Your public school division may or may not recognize the accreditation agency that accredited your kids’ online learning program or private school, so accreditation alone offers no guarantees.
In fact, some accrediting agencies have no clout at all, and some are scams at worst or marketing tools at best.
This doesn’t mean your child can’t get a good education from an online school or private school. It doesn’t mean that your child can’t get a good education using a curriculum that isn’t accredited (because it can’t be, since it’s a curriculum).
But it does mean you should think twice about spending money on any educational resource claiming to be “accredited” with the assumption that accreditation will hold value for your child.
Consider these things if your children plan to return to public school
If your plan is for your children to return to public school at some point, it's important to learn more about:
- Who determines grade level if/when your child returns to school?
- What happens when a homeschooled child returns to public school? (especially important for high school students!)
Your state’s Department of Education (DOE) or your local school division may have a specific list of pre-approved online schools or private schools from whom they will accept credit during a student’s high school years.
These schools may or may not be promoted as accredited, and their list might even only include virtual classes or a virtual school run by the state or local school division itself—public school at home.
We don’t know how the current situation might change public schools’ approach to accepting credits for work done at home. What we do know for now is that accreditation is not the magic ingredient that makes high school credits earned while homeschooling acceptable for transferring back to public school. We also know every state is different.
And guess what? While there are life-prep and college-prep things you should do while homeschooling high school, colleges don’t care if homeschoolers are using anything “accredited” either. Mind blown; I know!
I guess I'm confused. Does it matter, or does it not matter if your child goes to a accredited school? It sounds like if I try to send my kid back to public school at some point, if I pick the wrong home schooling program, they won't be able to go back because the curriculum didn't come from a institution they recognize?
"Your state’s Department of Education (DOE) or your local school division may have a specific list of pre-approved online schools or private schools from whom they will accept credit during a student’s high school years."
So then it could matter?
"[F]rom whom they will accept credit during a student's high school years" is the key part of that quote. If a student is returning to public school without any high school credits to transfer in, how and where work was done is usually irrelevant. It gets more complicated for students who have earned high school credits while homeschooling (because the diploma-issuing institution wants to control the quality of the credits used to earn the diploma).
Homeschooling is regulated at the state level so each state (and possibly each school district) has different rules about transferring credits in. Some will award credit toward graduation for work done while homeschooling, some may require testing to prove competency, and others may flat out refuse to accept anything that is not on their list of pre-approved online schools or private schools (see our post "When Your Child Goes from Homeschooling to Public School").
If your student plans to possibly return to public school after earning high school credits, research what your particular state and school district require and plan in advance (and keep up with changes in legislation or interpretation) to meet those requirements.
For others who might be reading this, I would be remiss if I didn't note that although homeschooling high school may seem intimidating to new homeschoolers, it is typically the easiest of all the levels. Students are more mature, have greater ownership of their education, and are able to be responsible for their own learning. There are usually many options for outsourcing work that parents cannot or do not want to take on (see our post "Resources for Homeschooling High School When Mom's Not the Expert"). Simply planning to homeschool all the way through may be the least stressful option.
This is downright terrifying. To say a homeschooling whatever isn’t/can’t/shouldn’t be accredited is to undermine the credibility of homeschooling.
The credibility of homeschooling is not and has never been due to accreditation of any kind.
We stand by our statement that homeschool curriculum cannot be accredited. Only schools/programs can be accredited. "Accreditation is offered to institutions by accrediting agencies (different agencies accredit public schools, private schools, and university model schools at the primary/secondary level, and a whole different set accredits institutions of higher education). These schools and universities can be accredited because they are institutions."